Connect with us
Photo by John Rivera/Icon Sportswire

Scouting Notes

Marino | 6-pack Thursday

Merry Christmas, Happy New Year and welcome to the latest edition of 6-pack Thursday where I drop a half-dozen NFL Draft takes and nuggets for your reading pleasure on a weekly basis. Let’s crack this thing open.

Josh Rosen and Sam Darnold make noise with comments

Rosen and Darnold figure to be among the first five or ten selections next April and their recent comments promise to be over-analyzed.

Both are perfectly fine statements and don’t warrant over-analysis. And while NFL teams likely prefer Darnold’s statement, they definitively prefer Rosen’s ability to throw a football.

Prediction:  Rosen smooths things over once he hires an agent and meets the Cleveland brass and is ultimately selected No. 1 overall by the Browns.

Could Clelin Ferrell be selected over Bradley Chubb?

My latest 2018 Mock Draft was released on Christmas Day and many were perplexed that I had Clemson EDGE Clelin Ferrell getting drafted one spot higher than NC State EDGE Bradley Chubb. Slow your roll if you don’t think I like Chubb – I have him getting selected in the top five.

The reality is that I believe Ferrell has better physical traits that may lead to an earlier selection than Chubb. He is longer, more explosive and more flexible than Chubb who is more of a technician with outstanding power.

They are both excellent prospects but it’s not far-fetched to think Ferrell may ultimately get selected higher.

Examining the Top-10 Wide Receiver

In last week’s 6-pack, I talked about the return of the top-10 running back and how there was an uptick in returns from recent selections. While the top-10 running back has returned, perhaps the top-10 receiver should go away. Here’s the full list since 2005.

Year Overall Pick Player Team
2005 3 Braylon Edwards Browns
2005 7 Troy Williamson Vikings
2005 10 Mike Williams Lions
2007 2 Calvin Johnson Lions
2007 9 Ted Ginn Dolphins
2009 7 Derrius Heyward-Bey Raiders
2009 9 Michael Crabtree 49ers
2011 4 AJ Green Bengals
2011 6 Julio Jones Falcons
2012 5 Justin Blackmon Jaguars
2013 8 Tavon Austin Rams
2014 4 Sammy Watkins Bills
2014 7 Mike Evans Buccs
2015 4 Amari Cooper Raiders
2015 7 Kevin White Bears
2017 5 Corey Davis Titans
2017 7 Mike Williams Chargers
2017 9 John Ross Bengals


Out of 18 top-10 receivers drafted since 2005, arguably five or six have emerged so far as true No. 1 targets. Even if you don’t factor in the three 2017 rookies that haven’t been given a fair shot to develop, the returns have been collectively very poor.

We are quick to say that teams should wait on taking running backs but perhaps the truth is it’s better to wait on receivers. With the 2018 crop of receivers lacking premier talent at the top, it will be interesting to see how things unfold in April.

Some have cooled on Texas OT Connor Williams

There has been some negative buzz recently around Williams and that he played poorly this season in comparison to his 2015 and 2016 tape.  (Click on this tweet and read the replies to learn more)

While I respect many of the analysts who replied in that thread and enjoy learning from several of them, don’t count me in the anti-Williams camp. I recognize he isn’t overly long and needs refinement with his footwork but he’s a firm first round talent for me.

Williams nimble feet, ability to mirror pass rusher and excellent play strength project him to a left tackle role at the next level. Capable of excelling in both power-gap and zone blocking run concepts, Williams is a scheme-transcendent player. Williams does need to work on some technical issues with his hands and body control but he has the upside to be a plug and play left tackle in the NFL. A team that needs a blindside protector would be well-served to invest in Williams. At a minimum, Williams has immense potential at guard.

Big test ahead for Mason Rudolph

I’ll be in Orlando on Thursday to cover the Camping World Bowl between Oklahoma State and Virginia Tech and it’s one of the Bowl matchups I’m most excited for. OK State’s high-flying passing game is powered by seniors QB Mason Rudolph, WR James Washington and WR Marcel Ateman and the Hokies will arguably be the best defense they’ve faced in their career.

While one game does not define a career, the Hokies defense is loaded with NFL talent and an aggressive scheme under the direction of Bud Foster. Senior cornerbacks Greg Stroman and Brandon Facyson are Sunday players that will provide a considerable challenge for Rudolph, Ateman and Washington.

Rudolph has faced criticism for how he reacts when pressured and the Hokies will certainly bring the heat on Thursday. I’ll also be curious as to which NFL personnel is in the press box with me. Stay tuned.

CFB Playoff Predictions

By the time next week’s edition of 6-pack Thursday is published, the CFB playoff games will have come and gone so I wanted to go on record with my picks.

Give me Georgia over Oklahoma. In a matchup of premier offense vs premier defense, give me Georgia and its defense. While Oklahoma fields Baker Mayfield who is the most outstanding offensive playmaker in football, Georgia’s stout defense and physical rushing attack will be too much for the Sooners. Georgia 24, Oklahoma 17.

I like Alabama (not confidently) to knock off No. 1 Clemson. I think the biggest difference in this year’s game when compared to the previous two is that they square off in the first round of the playoffs and not the National Championship. The extra time to prepare favors Nick Saban and the Crimson Tide. If there was only one week to prepare, I’d feel good about Clemson’s chances but that’s not the case this time. Alabama 23, Clemson 20.

If you’re still thirsty after this 6-pack, catch up on others you may have missed.

12/7/2017 6-pack Thursday

12/14/2017 6-pack Thursday 

12/21/2017 6-pack Thursday

Joe Marino

Marino began his career as the Assistant Editor for USA Today Digital Properties Draft Sites Network in 2011. A member of the FWAA, Marino writes about the NFL, College Football and NFL Draft for FanRag Sports.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Scouting Notes

To Top